He was enjoying his third cup of coffee when she walked in through the front door, the one with the brass knob and the sign offering the instructions, “Turn this way.” It wasn’t condescending; the knob’s direction was counterintuitive and after enough consecutive months of people shaking the door in frustrated attempts to open it, the coffee shop decided to put a sign up.
Her cheeks were pink with the cold and he tried to find nothing beautiful about them. Kevin was still in the developing phases of loathing post lust. It was hard to think of someone that he once wanted to spend every minute of every day with as unattractive just because they weren’t seeing each other anymore. That was her choice, not his, though when both of them discussed the break-up they would profess it was mutual. That way, Jessie didn’t look like a heartless bitch and Kevin didn’t come across as a pathetic loser. It worked out better for both of them.
Kevin saw her before she saw him but pretended that he didn’t, continuing to talk to his friend about holiday traveling and New Year’s plans he said would commit to but knew he would flake on at the last minute. He’d frankly rather shove the whole evening down a garbage chute and just wake up sometime in 2011, at a fair distance from the worst winter of his life.
“Hey!” he heard. It was her voice, filled with a jilted awkwardness that was never reserved for him in the past. They hadn’t seen each other since September 23rd, not that he knew the date by heart but it was his birthday. She dumped him on his fucking birthday in the garbage bag laden hallway of his apartment building.
Jessie, I hate you.
Jessie, I hate you.
Jessie, I hate you.
Kevin took a sip of his coffee, pretending that he didn’t feel his cheeks flush and that his arms hadn’t gone completely limp. He held onto his cup, praying that it didn’t fall straight out of his hands. “Oh, hey,” he said, feeling his friend back away from the conversation like a cartoon animal that had just stumbled upon a sleeping bear. Half of their friends were of the mutual kind; everyone knew.
“How are you?” Jessie asked. Kevin hated these questions because no one ever told the truth except maybe British people; British people were okay with the daily miseries of their own existence. There was no reason to lie; we all felt the same most of the time anyway, right?
“Great, yeah. Like fucking amazing.”
He regretted the words as soon they came out of his mouth, hearing his seventh grade literature teacher with the cropped blonde hair and the glasses from Lenscrafters saying, “The lady doth protest too much,” while standing in front of a white board.
“Yeah?”
There was an incredulousness in her voice that allowed him to hate her momentarily. Her look said something all its own – something like doubt, something like I’m-the-best-thing-you’ll-ever-have-and-I-didn’t-want-you. He held onto the moment in hopes that it would carry him through the rest of this interaction, forcing the urge to kiss her to dissipate.
“Well, that’s good then. Good for you. Anyway, I thought my friend would be here but…but I don’t think he is,” she said, pretending to scan the back of the room for a friend that very well may have still been right there. It was hard to tell if she felt uncomfortable or guilty; it was one of the two, maybe both. “I’m going to run,” she said, and then she wrapped her arms around his shoulders, filled with an apology that he didn’t ask for. She held on for an extended period of time that made Kevin cringe.
“Say hi to your mom for me if you’re going home,” she said, heading for the front door, turning the knob the right direction because this was her favorite coffee shop. This used to be their favorite coffee shop. His New Year’s resolution was to find another one, preferably in the Upper West Side. No one he knew went there. Like, literally no one.



